BUI Lawyer in Nocatee
Former DUI Prosecutor. Unbeaten Trial Record. Fighting for Boaters in St. Johns County.
A boating under the influence charge under Florida Statute 327.35 is a criminal offense, not a traffic citation. The consequences include potential jail time, fines, vessel impoundment, and a permanent record. If you were arrested on the waterways near Nocatee in St. Johns County, the case moves through St. Johns County court, and you need a defense attorney who understands the specific procedural rules that govern BUI cases on Florida waters.
Monroe Law, P.A. is a Jacksonville-based criminal defense firm representing clients in Duval, Clay, St. Johns, and Nassau counties. Founding attorney D. Scott Monroe began his legal career as the DUI Unit Prosecutor and Misdemeanor Supervisor for the Duval County State Attorney’s Office before moving to defense work. That background means we know how the prosecution builds these cases and where they can be challenged.
A BUI arrest near Nocatee carries real consequences. Call (904) 507-6194 now for a free consultation, available 24/7.
Why Choose Monroe Law, P.A. for a Nocatee BUI Case
We’ve handled trial matters without a trial loss to date. That’s not a marketing phrase; it’s a record we protect by preparing every case as though it will go before a jury. We keep our caseload manageable so each client gets direct attention from D. Scott Monroe, not an associate handed the file at the last minute. D. Scott Monroe holds an AV Preeminent® Rating from Martindale-Hubbell, the organization’s highest peer-rating standard, reflecting both legal ability and ethical standing.
When negotiation serves a client best, we negotiate hard. When trial is the right path, we’re prepared to go.
What Florida’s BUI Law Actually Covers
Florida Statute 327.35 makes it a crime to operate a vessel while impaired by alcohol or drugs, or with a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of 0.08% or higher. Impairment can be established even below that threshold based on an officer’s observations alone, which means a breathalyzer result isn’t the only evidence the state can use.
One detail that surprises many people: the boat doesn’t have to be moving. Florida applies the actual physical control standard to vessels, meaning someone sitting at the helm of an anchored or docked boat can still be arrested and charged with BUI.
Nocatee Waters & Local Enforcement
The waterways near Nocatee in St. Johns County include access points to the Intracoastal Waterway, which connects the St. Johns River to the north with the Matanzas and Tolomato Rivers to the south. Guana Lake, also known as Lake Ponte Vedra, sits roughly six miles away. These waters are patrolled by the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) alongside county and local law enforcement.
Because Nocatee sits within St. Johns County, a BUI stop on the surrounding waters is handled in St. Johns County court. We practice in that court and know its procedures.
-
“I recently worked with Monroe Law, P.A. and couldn't be more satisfied. From first contact, I felt assured and confident in their ability. The entire team is professional, knowledgeable, and dedicated. Their personal attention and care made me feel like a priority. Highly recommend.”- Ryan W.
-
“I had an excellent experience with Monroe Law, P.A. They are not only great lawyers but also genuinely great people. Throughout my case, they were extremely knowledgeable and provided clear, effective guidance. Always responsive and kept me informed every step of the way. Highly recommend.”- Xiomariah P.
-
“Monroe Law, P.A. was amazing in my time of need. The staff was caring, diligent, and highly professional, supporting me every step. Communication was great throughout the process. I'm very thankful I hired Monroe Law, P.A. for top-quality defense and excellent results.”- C. Elizabeth R.
-
Consecutively Earned Since 2019 -
Super Lawyers Since 2020 -
Consecutively Earned Since 2021 -
Avvo Client Choice Since 2016 -
America's Most Honored Lawyers (Top 1%) -
10 Best Attorney Since 2016 -
10 Best Law Firm Since 2023 -
Best DUI Defense Lawyers Since 2016 -
Best Criminal Defense Lawyers Since 2016 -
Lawyer of the Year 2025 -
Best of the Best 2026 -
Top 10 Criminal Defense Attorney 2025 -
Top 10 Criminal Defense Law Firm America's Best -
Top 10 DUI Defense Law Firm -
American Association of Attorney Advocates 2025 -
Lawyers of Distinction Since 2020 -
American Institute of Legal Advocates Since 2016 -
Law Firm of the Year 2025 -
Top 10 Criminal Defense 2018 -
.png.2603240814218.webp "Top 10 DUI Defense Since 2018")
Top 10 DUI Defense Since 2018 -
.2401311436550.png "Best Law Firm (2024)")
Best Law Firm (2024) -
Top 100 Trial Lawyers by The National Trial Lawyers -
2019 Leading Adviser Awards Winner -
Top 1%: DUI Defense -
Top 1%: Criminal Defense -
Top 1%: Drug Trafficking Defense -
Top 1%: White Collar Criminal Defense -
America's Top 100 Criminal Defense Attorneys Since 2020 -
.2309221118124.png "AIOLA: Elite Advocate Since 2018")
AIOLA: Elite Advocate Since 2018 -
-
Justia Lawyer Rating -
America's Most Honored Florida Lawyers
What to Do After a BUI Arrest Near Nocatee
The steps you take immediately after an arrest can affect your defense. Exercise your right to remain silent: you don’t have to answer questions beyond providing identifying information, and statements made on the water or at the dock can be used against you. You also have the right to speak with an attorney before and during any questioning.
Write down everything you can recall about the stop as soon as possible: the location on the water, the time, which agency conducted the stop, the officers’ names, if you learned them, and what was said. Details fade quickly, and preserving them gives your defense attorney more to work with.
How BUI Differs from a Standard DUI in Florida
BUI and DUI defense are related charges under Florida law, but the procedural rules differ in ways that matter for your defense.
- No Validated Field Sobriety Tests on Water: The standardized field sobriety tests used in DUI cases, such as the walk-and-turn or one-leg stand, haven’t been validated for use on a vessel. An unstable deck, wave action, and wind can all affect performance independent of any impairment, which limits the weight those observations can carry in court.
- Implied Consent on Florida Waters: Boaters are considered to have given implied consent to alcohol or drug testing if an officer with probable cause requests it. Before July 1, 2025, refusal carried only civil penalties. Under Trenton’s Law, refusal is now also a criminal offense, making the decision considerably more consequential.
- Zero-Tolerance Rule for Operators Under 21: Florida sets a separate BAC threshold of 0.02% for vessel operators under 21. A reading at or above that level is treated as a non-criminal infraction, with consequences including a mandatory boating safety course and community service, but it doesn’t carry the same criminal penalties as a standard BUI conviction.
- Cross-Enhancement Between BUI & DUI: Florida treats BUI and DUI convictions as related for sentencing-enhancement purposes. A prior BUI can count as a prior offense when sentencing on a later DUI, and a prior DUI can count when sentencing on a later BUI. If you have a prior conviction in either category, the stakes of the current charge are higher than they might appear.
Talk to a Boating Under the Influence Defense Attorney Today
BUI charges in St. Johns County move through the court system on a schedule that doesn’t wait. The sooner we can review the facts of your arrest, the more options may be available. Monroe Law, P.A. offers a free initial consultation and is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
Call (904) 507-6194 to speak with our defense team about your BUI case. We serve boaters arrested on the Intracoastal Waterway and the surrounding Nocatee-area waters in St. Johns County.